P
Just glue with whatever you find, with your structural requirements it'll be great! :)
 
  • Like
Svetspinnen and 1 other
  • Laddar…
When the 10 kg dumbbell had fallen two meters, its kinetic energy was the same as 90 kg falling 22 cm or 110 kg falling 18 cm.

Now, we do not know where the breaking point is, but if we assume that the dumbbell just barely managed to crack the step, then TS should be able to jump from one step down to the next, while someone weighing 110 kg should not do so.

There are certain shortcomings in the calculation, as the human body is more elastic than a dumbbell, but it provides some indication nonetheless. Some designer can surely calculate more accurately on the dimensioning.
 
  • Like
Roger Fundin and 3 others
  • Laddar…
If you want to prove that TS is wrong about their stairs by knocking them down, you should consider that a dumbbell probably attacks the step on a much smaller area than an average old man's foot (which I guess TS has).
 
D
What kind of wood is it? I would look at epoxy like SP, if it's oak there are special glues for that as well. I brought a special glue for oak back from the USA for the boat when the bow split. Unfortunately, I don't remember what the glue was called, but they also sold lingu which is banned here in Europe.
 
I am a bit curious about this staircase.

Is the reinforcement of the stringers with flat iron underneath a design or construction choice?
 
S
Alfredo Alfredo said:
Based on the pictures, I think there are good conditions for achieving high press pressure with a bunch of clamps. Do you mean that white glue would be more suitable here due to questionable fit?
It never becomes a perfect glue joint when the wood has cracked like that. There's always some small splinter that prevents a perfect fit.

I would make a new step. Least work/most durable.

D Danne824 said:
What type of wood is it? I would look at epoxy like SP, if it's oak there are special adhesives for that as well. I brought a special adhesive for oak from the USA for the boat when the bow split. Unfortunately, I don't remember what the adhesive was called, but they also carried Lignu, which is banned here in Europe.
Epoxy is a good adhesive and with filler it's strong even as a filler. But the cost of buying epoxy glue exceeds the cost of buying a spruce beam and making a new step.

What's forbidden with Lignu epoxy? It's sold in many Swedish stores.
 
D
D Danne824 said:
What kind of wood is it? I would look at epoxy like SP, if it's oak there are special glues for that too. I brought home from the USA a special glue for oak for the boat when the bow was splitting. Unfortunately, I don't remember what the glue was called but they carried lingu too which is prohibited here in Europe.
Found their website
https://www.rotdoctor.com/epoxy/epoxymain.html
 
D
S sinuslinus said:
There will never be a perfect glue joint when wood has cracked like that. Always some small splinter that prevents a perfect fit.

I would make a new step. Least work/most durable.

Epoxy is a good glue and with filler, it's strong even as a filler. But the cost of buying epoxy glue exceeds the cost of buying a spruce rule and making a new step.

What's forbidden with Lignu-epoxy? It's sold in a lot of Swedish stores.
The original was very hazardous to health according to our regulations. Had a really hard time getting the original. So I imported from the US, cost a fortune I can tell you, but being a nerd as I am.
 
G gbgustaf said:
There are certain shortcomings in the calculation, since the human body is more elastic than a dumbbell, but it provides an indication at least. Some designer can surely calculate more accurately on the dimensioning.
Not to mention the lack of relevance...
 
richardtenggren richardtenggren said:
Is it the crown jewel in terms of design? :geek:
:crysmile:
 
mexitegel mexitegel said:
I am a bit curious about this staircase.

Is the reinforcement of the stringers with flat iron underneath a design or construction choice?
Construction. They are recessed against the upper beam. The idea was just to have a bit more leeway in load-bearing capacity. Maybe unnecessary but felt right :)
 
Thomas59 Thomas59 said:
Incidentally, a properly constructed and sized staircase would easily withstand a 10kg dumbbell falling from 3 meters.
That's what I wanted to write.

As for "empiricism" TS:
Such empiricism was used in the Middle Ages. Does it hold up? Yes! It's good! But over time, someone noticed that not completely and not always. The King went up the stairs often in robes and it was fine, but he put on armor and now we have to wait for his son to grow up. And someone came up with the idea to introduce a factor of safety. But TS will get acquainted with this when he becomes more open to suggestions.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Roger Fundin and 1 other
  • Laddar…
S sturnus said:
That's what I wanted to write.

As for "empiricism" TS:
Such empiricism was used in the Middle Ages. Does it hold up? Yes! It's good!. But over time, someone noticed that not completely and not always. The King went up the stairs often in robes and it was fine, but he put on armor and now we have to wait for his son to grow up. And someone came up with the idea to introduce a factor of safety. But TS will get acquainted with this when he becomes more open to suggestions
Haha. Is this when you come and drag me to the Whipping Post? :)
 
D DanMicke said:
Haha.
No... here's a reason to cry...
I won't say anything about you insisting on repairing this step, although it is easy to reproduce. And you say you can do without him for a week. May you not forget it when you go down these stairs sleepily at night.
 
  • Like
Roger Fundin
  • Laddar…
Och. Tänkte inte på det. Alls ;)
 
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.