Hi!
I wonder if it is structurally OK to lay the beams horizontally instead of vertically on a carport with a storage room measuring 9x4.7m.
The pictures were taken on 2 different days, the carpenter has cut into the wooden beam to "lower" the roof/carport by 3-4CM. Is it OK or is there a risk they might collapse?

Grateful for advice!
Best regards
 
  • Wooden beam cut to lower a carport roof by 3-4 cm in a construction project, with red circle highlighting the cut area.
  • Wooden beam cut for lowering carport roof; questions about construction safety and stability raised.
  • Wooden beams on a carport construction site, one beam is cut to lower the roof. Trees visible in the background at night.
  • Construction site with wooden beams placed horizontally on a carport frame. A ladder and support structures are visible, questioning stability adjustments.
  • Wooden beams in a construction project showing modifications for lowering a carport roof by cutting 3-4 cm into the beams, with outdoor background.
Beams are usually standing.

Is there a construction drawing or is he building freestyle?

If a building permit was involved, there should be a drawing for the project.
 
R Robert-san01 said:
You usually have beams standing.

Is there a construction drawing, or is he building freestyle?

If there was a building permit involved, there should be a drawing for the project.
Really feels like freestyle. There's a building permit, but no detailed construction drawing, maybe my mistake? New homeowner, so fairly green about the whole thing. More of an architectural drawing for the building permit that got approved, but in the drawing, you can't really see how things should be built. More about which materials to use, but not really "how." Can post an example here. Not the official drawing, the official is 3 degrees. Here we recently tested with 6 degrees, and it's not really possible to get a larger slope because it becomes too low.

The big question is, do you think it will collapse because they are lying down, or does it not matter?
 
  • Building elevation sketch showing a structure with a 6-degree sloped roof, detailed measurements, materials, and construction elements labeled in Swedish.
D denis0716 said:
The big question is, do you think it will collapse because they're lying down or does it not matter?
If you take the same pieces and just turn them down, there will be five directions on the fibers, and it will collapse, I would think. You can check here what the difference is if you turn them incorrectly.

https://www.traguiden.se/om-tra/mat...na,fibrerna än vinkelrätt mot fiberriktningen.

So I would think it is much better as the carpenter has done.
 
If there is a post under each rafter/beam, there shouldn't be any problems, but otherwise, the hammarbandet should be upright. If the height is important, the hammarbandet could have been upright and used a joist hanger - but I'm not a designer...
 
It should be upright; you'll get a completely different strength that way. I built a carport myself this summer and did it like this, see picture. I took the posts at the top and attached an upright beam with through carriage bolts in each post. Then a horizontal beam on top that I screwed from above. Good luck.
Wooden frame of a carport under construction, featuring vertical posts with a horizontal top beam and cross braces against a background of trees.
 
  • Like
Robert-san01
  • Laddar…
S
Wall plates are laid horizontally, whereas load-bearing beams are placed vertically. If the roof trusses are positioned directly under a load-bearing beam, then it's probably okay. But otherwise, it might be problematic if a roof truss ends up between two beams without an inset load-bearing beam. Haven't you had an engineer calculate the construction? Offhand, I also think the timber dimensions are oddly chosen.

PM me if you want me to take a look at it.
 
  • Like
Robert-san01 and 2 others
  • Laddar…
MultiMan
You must have a supporting post under each rafter if you have the hammarbandet lying down (or whatever it's called here, bärlina?) because such a thin plank lying flat has practically no stiffness at all in that direction. The rafters resting on such a lying board will sag where there are no posts underneath, so you'll end up with a roller coaster.
 
Click here to reply
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.