Hello!

I have a small problem and need tips on solutions. Thanks in advance!

A large hole in a wall above a wooden handrail, circled in red, where a screw plug for a handrail was previously inserted.
Here was one of three screws holding a handrail. There was a plug not intended for plasterboard but rather concrete. It appeared to have been glued at least once and has now given way, leaving a large hole about 18mm.

A metal screw and a cylindrical black mount are placed on a wooden surface. The screw shows signs of wear.
Here is the screw. 10mm in diameter.

A screw protruding from a white wall, used for attaching a handrail, showing a plug behind the screw head, in a home setting with light wooden floor. Wall with a large hole from a detached screw, revealing a plug behind a loose handrail bracket.
Example of another screw that is higher up. You can see the plug behind the "cap". At the moment, this one is holding firmly :)

Wooden handrail on a striped rug, showing screw holes for railing attachment, with one having an issue needing repair or reinforcement.
The handrail.

I would prefer not to make new holes in either the wall or the handrail, but I might have to consider it if there are no other solutions.

So far, I have not found a larger universal plug than 12mm (at Bauhaus), which is too small to cover the hole. I assume there are larger ones available? At the same time, the plug must grip a 10mm screw.

Can the plasterboard be repaired and then used for new mounting, or is there too great a risk of it all coming loose again?
 
Is there really nothing to screw into?
If not, I could imagine using
Fishers fil&fix,
 
tommib
That type of handrail really shouldn't hang just in plasterboard. If it does, I would argue that it's incorrectly built. The brackets for the handrail should be attached to studs.
 
  • Like
Julio Torrez and 2 others
  • Laddar…
tommib tommib said:
That type of handrail should definitely not hang only in plaster. If it does, I would claim that it is built incorrectly. The brackets for the handrail should be attached to the studs.
Mm, it's clearly not well done. :confused:
 
tommib
I understand that it's not very appealing to do the right thing, i.e. either locate the studs and attach the brackets there, or tear down the wall and ensure you have proper anchor points where the brackets should be, but that's pretty much the only thing I can recommend.

A quick-fix could be to glue plywood onto the drywall and screw into that. You'd have to use substantial pieces. Yes, it will be ugly.
 
First and foremost, it's probably best to clarify whether it's really just plaster where the attachment points are. Remove the plug and shine in with a light? It should become quite apparent soon if there's an open wall behind or if it's something other than just plaster.
 
Peter2400 Peter2400 said:
Is there really nothing to screw into behind it? If there isn't, I would consider using Fisher's file&fix, [media]
I tried this: https://www.bauhaus.se/epoxylim-loctite-repair-putty-48g

Didn't work very well on plaster, and there's nothing behind it to anchor into. Now leaning towards plan B; buying a new handrail, drilling holes where the studs are, and installing it there.
 
S Stefan1972 said:
The original poster should probably first clarify whether the anchor points are truly only in drywall. Remove the plug and shine a light inside? It should become clear quite soon if there's an open wall behind or if it's something other than just drywall.
The middle anchor point is in beadboard/wood paneling (unsure what it's called). It's very firmly set.
Ceiling and wall with beadboard paneling and mount points, showing a missing rod.

Looks like I'll need to get a new rod and find a stud this time.
 
tommib
As mentioned, you could also cut the plaster where the previous brace was and reinforce behind it. It will involve some spackling and painting work, but you can use the handrail you already have.
 
  • Like
Ronny68
  • Laddar…
I would have tried with a molly plug, try to find one with the same dimension on the thread as the knob, then replace that screw with a piece of threaded rod.
 
  • Like
Ronny68
  • Laddar…
Click here to reply
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.