I am going to build a pergola and use posts 150 x 150 mm, meaning quite thick. Ideally, I would not like to use post shoes that are visible on the sides of the post, but a more "invisible" model. Does anyone know if there are alternatives with a plate (preferably about 150x150 or slightly smaller) that can be screwed into the bottom of the post and can attach to a pier? I imagine the post should be about 5 cm above the pier.
 
  • Like
Mr Geisler
  • Laddar…
J
Post shoe for screwing into end grain isn't really a good idea, but the question has come up before and there was at least a picture then. As mentioned, it's not good to screw into end grain, which you have to do if it should be invisible. The screw/threads don't really hold in that direction. Can't they be cast in? https://www.byggahus.se/forum/threads/stolpsko-foer-traepelare.310313/
 
Last edited:
J Jocke Best said:
Post shoe for screwing into end grain is probably not really a good idea, but the question has been raised before and there was at least one picture. As mentioned, it's not good to screw into end grain, which you have to do if it is to be invisible. The screw/threads don't really grip in that direction. Can't they be cast in place?
[link]
Yes, that's true. I'll probably have to go with a post shoe anyway, but it could be countersunk into the beam, and then the effect is almost the same.
 
This Fence Post Shoe type A from Joma becomes almost invisible. Joma post base type A, designed for structural support, showing a metal base plate with holes for mounting.
 
  • Like
sepani
  • Laddar…
Matti_75 Matti_75 said:
This Stolpsko type A from Joma becomes almost invisible.
[image]
Terribly bad at taking lateral loads though, so it’s important there isn't much of that.
 
  • Like
Claes Sörmland and 1 other
  • Laddar…
T Tjrex said:
Terribly bad at handling lateral loads though, so it's important there's not much of that.
Yes. I'm wondering if even a post shoe will be too weak? You know, the kind that is screwed into the foundation. The post is 150x150x2400mm and obviously weighs a lot. Plus the beams on top for the pergola.
 
Depends a bit on how you build the rest of the pergola.
With braces up between the posts and the frame, for example in wrought iron, making it sturdy, you won't have any significant lateral forces.
But if you're not going to have that, each separate post needs to be secured firmly in every direction.
 
Isakare Isakare said:
Depends a bit on how you build the rest of the pergola.
With diagonal braces between the posts and frame, for example in wrought iron, making it sturdy, you won't have major lateral forces.
But if you don't plan to have that, then each individual post needs to be secured properly in all directions.
The plan is not to have any diagonal braces except in the corners and then as short as possible. Maybe I should cast footings and put iron in them, but I prefer to avoid that. I know st Eriks has pre-made ones, but they are very heavy to handle.
 
Run a pergola in steel and weld!
 
T Tjrex said:
Terribly bad at taking lateral loads though so it's important that there's not much of that.
No worse than any other post shoe. Besides, we are talking about a Pergola.
 
  • Like
mexitegel and 1 other
  • Laddar…
Recess plinth iron? That is, make notches in the posts so that the irons are at the same level as the surface of the post. Putty and then paint over it so it's barely visible. Otherwise, saw away more wood, recess the irons, and then glue back what was sawed off.

The older method was to cast in a substantial round rod and drill a corresponding hole in the post.
 
  • Like
sepani and 1 other
  • Laddar…
Maybe take a regular four-inch post shoe, notch it into the post. Then you can glue on some wood pieces after you've screwed it in.
 
Claes Sörmland
No, not post shoe!

I've made that mistake with a pergola, everything wobbles. Sturdy post supports on both sides of the post down into the concrete foundation.

If it's NTR-A, you can also cast the post directly into the concrete. It sounds "ghetto," but I've done it for simpler fences and posts in the garden according to instructions in a book from the '70s. And it works; no rot for 15 years now, and it's very stable. But as mentioned, NTR-A-rated pressure-treated is required for this. Which is the standard for posts in our country. And if it's going to last 50 or 100 years, it might not be a good idea.
 
  • Like
Mr Geisler and 1 other
  • Laddar…
Claes Sörmland Claes Sörmland said:
No, not post shoes!

I made that mistake with a pergola, everything sways. Sturdy anchor brackets on both sides of the post down into the concrete footing.

If it's NTR-A, you can also cast the post directly into the concrete. It sounds "getto," but I've done it for simpler fences and posts in the garden according to instructions in a book from the 70s. And it works, no rot for 15 years now, and it's very stable. But as mentioned, NTR-A-rated pressure-treated is required for this. Which is standard for posts in our country. And if it's supposed to last 50 or 100 years, it's probably not a good idea.
It sounds like I'll have to cast and set anchor brackets. I had hoped to avoid that. The only alternative for my 150x150 posts seems to be the giant footings from St Eriks. But maybe that will be easiest after all…
 
S sepani said:
It sounds like I might have to cast and set post anchors. Had hoped to avoid that. The only alternative for my 150x150 posts seems to be the giant anchors from St Eriks. But maybe that will be easiest anyway…
The alternative is to buy a post anchor with a fixed 4 inches and notch the post 1 inch from each side? Maybe that works. Or will the post be weakened…? I would have preferred to find 5 inches to avoid removing so much, but that doesn't seem to exist…
 
Last edited:
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.