The compressive strength of concrete is primarily determined by the ratio of its components. Its flexural strength depends on the size and positioning of the reinforcement. The dead weight of timber structures is not very high. The largest loads occur as live loads from furniture and people, as well as from snow loads.
 
  • Like
Martin_B
  • Laddar…
Martin_B
Okay.

Yes, of course, the Romans built quite a bit with unreinforced concrete and it still holds, having lasted for many hundreds of years.

Isn't it standard, for example, for ready-mixed concrete bags to have fiber reinforcement? This way the constructions would be safer, even without reinforcement. Reinforcement is, after all, a disadvantage as it damages the concrete construction over time due to rust.
 
Martin_B
J justusandersson said:
The compressive strength of concrete is primarily determined by the ratio of the ingredients. Its flexural strength is determined by the size and placement of the reinforcement. The self-weight of wood structures is not very high. The largest loads occur as live loads from furniture and people, as well as snow load.
Normal concrete mix can withstand about 40 MPa? And that's slightly over 400kg / square centimeter.

So a pillar 20 x 20 cm, with say 70 cm height as in the previous examples, should be able to handle 160 tons. (20 x 20 = 400 cm2 x 0.4 tons = 160 tons).

So for example, 10 of such unreinforced concrete pillars should be able to support a structure that weighs 1600 tons before the concrete construction fails...
I guess a whole house might weigh 100-150 tons, so it should actually hold up by a large margin.

And then the real question is how long such a construction could stand on unreinforced concrete before it collapses (under normal ground conditions).
 
The Pantheon is built with unreinforced concrete and it still stands...
 
  • Like
Erik9005
  • Laddar…
Leca withstands 3MPa, so a block of 59x19 cm can at best sustain a distributed load of about 34 tons.
 
  • Like
hildingvi
  • Laddar…
Click here to reply
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.