13,777 views ·
34 replies
14k views
34 replies
Concrete screw breaks during installation
I will screw a load-bearing beam into a concrete pier. I bought these screws after a recommendation at the hardware store: https://www.beijerbygg.se/privat/sv...betongskruv/betongskruv-fbs-ii-us-cp-ultracut
Dimension 6 x 100. Drilled a 6 mm hole as instructed. The screw goes in a few turns then becomes very tight, and when I applied more force, it simply broke. Is a larger hole needed or what could otherwise be wrong?
Dimension 6 x 100. Drilled a 6 mm hole as instructed. The screw goes in a few turns then becomes very tight, and when I applied more force, it simply broke. Is a larger hole needed or what could otherwise be wrong?
The screws you link to are available in 8-10-12 mm, not 6 mm. I have no experience with these, someone with experience may comment further.
I would have used expanderbult.
I would have used expanderbult.
Just 6mm can be a bit tricky. I always use a 1/4” drill for these. But I've never experienced them breaking. What kind of drill bit do you have and do you clean the hole sufficiently and drill deep enough?
Load-bearing beam 45 X ?, the expander should be long enough so that the inner part with the thread is about 2 cm into the hole. This is because it will creep out about 1 cm when the nut is tightened to grip the hole. Make sure it has a long thread so it can be retightened. It's advisable to have the nut at the edge when it's driven in, to prevent the thread from being deformed. Additionally, drill the load-bearing beam first, clamp it in place, and then drill through the holes in the beam. Drilling the post first and then trying to level the load-bearing beam is bound to succeed.
Worn drill?
I have similar experience with concrete screws that I also bought on recommendation from the hardware store. Had to be quite careful when screwing. About 15% or so broke, so it wasn't completely useless, but next time I'll probably go with expanderbult.
It seems like the casting mold for the concrete is an eternit pipe. Personally, I'm not hysterically afraid of asbestos (as some are) but it might be a good idea not to disturb the surface too much.
A. Drill deeper than the screw's length, at least one cm more.
B. Blow out the hole thoroughly, preferably with compressed air.
C. Good drill bit, preferably Hilti with 4 cutting edges that is not worn.
D. Use an impact driver and stop immediately if it comes to a halt.
But preferably, use an expander instead, it is 100 times better, personally, I hate concrete screws.
B. Blow out the hole thoroughly, preferably with compressed air.
C. Good drill bit, preferably Hilti with 4 cutting edges that is not worn.
D. Use an impact driver and stop immediately if it comes to a halt.
But preferably, use an expander instead, it is 100 times better, personally, I hate concrete screws.


