Hello everyone,

My wife and I have had an iron railing made for our balcony. I think it looks crooked, especially in the left section (see the picture). By crooked, I mean that the horizontal flat bars are not entirely straight. The blacksmith says this is unavoidable because the material moves when you weld it. Even so, when I look at other balcony railings on other houses, they look completely straight and symmetrical.

What do you think? Should I point this out?

Thank you very much in advance!
 
  • Iron balcony railing with scroll designs leaning against a wooden fence, left section appears crooked; grass and fallen leaves in foreground.
They do look straight in the picture, but the welder is correct that the material contracts when welded. However, this is usually straightened after welding so it becomes straight and neat.
 
  • Like
Ulric and 1 other
  • Laddar…
harry73
I don't see what you mean, but I think that small deviations add character and show that it is craftsmanship.
 
  • Like
Elektra and 7 others
  • Laddar…
Left section, top horizontal flat iron.
Looks like it's sagging a bit in the middle.
 
Sure, there might be some movement when welding, but for a balcony railing, you should use material strong enough so it doesn't matter.

Place something straight on top and see how much it differs?
 
Doesn't matter if it's heavy material, it will warp anyway, but you align it after welding.
 
Why not complement with a wooden rail?

As an example, something like this:

Rounded wooden handrail end piece for deck railings from ALTANBYGGE.nu.
 
  • Wooden handrail with rounded top and grooved bottom, used as an example for construction projects.
  • Like
Anna_H
  • Laddar…
If it's crooked, the blacksmith should fix it. We ordered a balcony railing last winter also with slightly slimmer dimensions and it's perfectly straight. So it is possible to get it completely straight. Then you can also complain about the joining of the pieces. It looks terribly ugly to screw the parts together with the flat irons they've welded on.
 
  • Like
J-stedt
  • Laddar…
Placing a wooden cap on top becomes both bulky, ugly, and requires a lot of maintenance. An emergency fix that can barely be called a fix at all for the type of railing that TS has ordered.
 
  • Like
SonnyListon and 2 others
  • Laddar…
We have considered wooden handrails but will probably keep the railing as it is.
 
Craftsmanship! Hard to tell from the picture, but I don't think you'll be bothered by it once it's in place. If you study things in detail, fences, wallpaper, moldings, or whatever it may be, not everything is one hundred percent perfect. I believe it's most important that it gives a good overall impression and isn't eye-catching.
 
  • Like
Thomas_Blekinge
  • Laddar…
A couple of more pictures Wrought iron fence with scroll design in front of a wooden wall, dimly lit.
A hand pointing to a gap between a metal railing and a wall in a dimly lit setting.
 
Probably because the ornaments are uneven, which is quite common for them to be. The problem is that the railing is galvanized, making it difficult to remedy effectively at this stage.
 
  • Like
JSvenonius
  • Laddar…
Not entirely uncommon for things to warp during galvanization but a long bend should not be a problem to straighten; place the railing on a piece of wood and hang on the sides and it will become straight.
 
About to go wild with the folding rule. Galvningen may be the blacksmith's migraine...
 
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.