I'm going to attempt to repair a plastered wall (chimney) and need all the tips and advice you have, described as simply and pedagogically as possible.
 
  • Peeling plaster wall with damaged chimney in need of repair, showing exposed brick and cracked surface, next to a white ceramic stove.
  • Close-up of a damaged plastered wall with visible cracks and peeling paint, needing repair.
  • Plastered wall with peeling sections, spirit level leaned against it, wooden frame and fireplace in view, part of a renovation project.
  • A worn plastered wall with cracks and peeling sections, showing areas that may need repair and restoration.
C
The first and last images seemingly show an old measure that has failed (poor adhesion to the original plaster). So one should probably consider taking down the rest of the outer plaster layer as well.

Number 2, in my opinion, should be to assess the condition of what's left. Everything that's loose is usually taken down, and then you need to consider if there is enough left to make it worth repairing, or if you should knock it all down and start over.
 
It also looks like you have black mold there on the walls... Wash it off with mold cleaner or bleach.
Scrape away all the loose parts and tap on the wall to see where it is "bom" (i.e., loose) and knock that down as well.
Then apply cement slurry and plaster. B-plaster should work well.
If you haven't plastered before, use plaster guides.
Depending on how smooth a surface you want, you can finish it with a plank (rough), a plastic float (semi-rough), or a metal spatula for a fine surface.
 
C
anders07 anders07 said:
Then apply cement slurry and plaster. B plaster should work fine.
B plaster on a soft lime plaster is not a good combination. It will cause cracking where the materials meet.
 
  • Like
Anonymiserad 170696
  • Laddar…
C cpalm said:
B-render on a soft lime render is not a good combination. If nothing else, there will be cracking where the materials meet.
How do you know it's lime render?
 
C
anders07 anders07 said:
How do you know it's lime plaster?
There was nothing else at the time this was done.
 
  • Like
anders07
  • Laddar…
So what do you think? Lime plaster? Or are the walls done for?
 
N nalli said:
So what do you think? Lime plaster? Or are the walls done for?
No, but it might be easier to apply fiber cement boards and then plaster on them... Then you know it will hold.

I think the plaster looks a bit too sharp/harsh to be lime plaster, but it's hard to say for sure from the pictures. It could be lime plaster initially, and someone has repaired with cement mortar, which is why it's falling off.
 
  • Like
Anonymiserad 170696
  • Laddar…
C cpalm said:
The first and last images apparently show an old measure that has failed (poor adhesion to the original plaster). So there, you probably need to consider taking down the rest of the outer layer of plaster as well.

Number 2, in my opinion, should be to assess the condition of what's left. Everything that's loose is usually taken down, and then you need to consider whether there's enough left to make it worth repairing, or if you should knock everything down and start over from scratch.
And how do you then start over?
 
C
anders07 anders07 said:
It could be lime plaster from the beginning and someone repaired it with cement mortar, which is why it falls down.
Yes, the outer layer is possibly KC mortar, but judging by the newsprint there it also looks quite old. Lime-cement mortar began to be used sometime in the 40s.

N nalli said:
And how do you then start over?
Do you mean if you decide to completely knock down a wall?
Yes, then you have a bit more freedom of choice, of course. Personally, I would build it up with the same traditional technique/material - 4 mm air-hardening lime plaster 1:2 applied in perhaps 3 layers of about one centimeter thick each. The last layer is smoothed against slats that can be arranged in various ways and finished with a float. Depending on what you plan to do with the wall, it might not necessarily need to be rendered with fine plaster afterward.

Is the base consistently masonry, or do you have plaster on wood somewhere?

I know you wanted a detailed workflow, but it's quite extensive to attempt to draft some kind of plastering school here. Unfortunately, it seems my favorite mason has disappeared from YouTube, otherwise, I would have linked to his channel.
 
  • Like
Anonymiserad 170696
  • Laddar…
C cpalm said:
Yes, the outer layer is potentially KC mortar, but judging by the newspaper there, it also looks quite old. Lime-cement mortar started to be used sometime in the 40s.

Do you mean if you decide to completely knock down a wall? Yes, you have a bit more freedom of choice then, of course. Personally, I would rebuild it with the same traditional technique/material - 4 mm air-hardened lime plaster 1:2 applied in perhaps 3 cm thick layers. The final layer is leveled off using strips that can be arranged in various ways and then finished smooth. Depending on what you plan to do with the wall, it doesn’t necessarily need to be finished with fine plaster afterward.

Is the base consistently masonry, or do you have plaster on wood somewhere?

I know you wanted a detailed step-by-step guide, but it becomes quite extensive to try to write a sort of plastering school here. Unfortunately, my favorite plasterer seems to have disappeared from YouTube, otherwise, I would have linked to his channel.
It's an old croft, so I guess it’ll have to be done as you say. The part I’ve chipped away seems to be more powdery inside (a little more yellow? And the outer part is more gray and harder. Can a completely inexperienced person plaster with lime plaster?
 
C
N nalli said:
Can a completely inexperienced person manage to plaster with lime plaster?
Lime plaster is not more difficult than any other type of plaster mix, so to speak. But if you're going to plaster an entire wall section with good results, it's not certain you'll succeed if you ask me. I've personally hired professionals for that.
 
  • Like
Anonymiserad 170696
  • Laddar…
Me
C cpalm said:
Lime plaster is not more difficult than any other plaster, so to speak.
But if you're going to plaster an entire wall section with good results, it's not obvious that you'll succeed if you ask me. Personally, I have hired professionals for that.
But I think it's not dangerous to try, if everything falls down, you can hire someone later 😊
 
  • Like
cpalm
  • Laddar…
C cpalm said:
Lime plaster is not more difficult than any other plaster, so to speak.
But if you are going to plaster an entire wall section with good results, it's not obvious that you will succeed if you ask me. Personally, I have hired professionals for that.
 
  • Old tiled stove and crumbling plaster wall in a partially renovated room with debris on the floor.
Collapsed masses, tips?
 
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.