The outer staircase at my mother-in-law's house is starting to fall apart, especially certain planks. I've promised to fix it. Should I just replace them all to make it a nice and uniform staircase? The house otherwise is not in top condition, so that might be a bit overkill...

Can you achieve a somewhat uniform appearance if you only replace some of the planks? I guess it should be pressure-treated? But it's not that easy to paint, especially not right away...

Old wooden porch steps with visible wear and some damaged planks. A pot of flowers sits on the steps, hinting at a need for repair or replacement. Wooden outdoor steps with damaged planks beside a house, featuring a bucket with blooming pink flowers, grass surrounding the area. Wooden outdoor steps with worn planks, attached to a house with a red and white exterior, showing signs of wear and in need of repair.
 
Last edited:
Just replace the decking, it's a maximum of 300 bucks in material costs and 2-3 hours of work to tear down and relay, you can also have a couple of beers in that time (unless the frame is completely rotten too, then it's a bit more work)
 
  • Like
Stefan N and 1 other
  • Laddar…
P patfred said:
Just replace the decking, it's a maximum of 300 bucks in material costs and 2 - 3 hours of work to tear down and re-lay it, you can even enjoy a couple of beers in that time (unless the frame is also completely rotten, then it's a bit more work)
The frame is metal (not so visible in the pictures), and there's nothing wrong with it. I believe the biggest job will be loosening the bolts (I think there are nuts underneath).

Is decking always pressure-treated?
 
osiris osiris said:
The frame is metal (doesn't show very well in the pictures), and there's nothing wrong with it. I think the biggest job will be getting the bolts off (I think there are nuts underneath).

Is decking always pressure treated?
Mm the bolts do look a bit troublesome indeed. You should go with pressure-treated wood, yes, it costs about 13kr per linear meter. It's pretty much the cheapest wood you can find and very standard for decking.
 
Don't bother messing with the nuts, it's just a waste of time. Pry off the boards with a crowbar and cut the nuts with an angle grinder. Drill new holes if necessary.

Otherwise, I agree: buy pressure-treated decking, replace everything while you're at it, otherwise, the same problem will keep happening over and over.
 
  • Like
SaabNiklas and 2 others
  • Laddar…
If the bolts can't be removed in the usual way after a dose of 556, it's time to bring out the angle grinder. Cut one end and hammer it out. Don't be stingy with replacing a few boards; take them all at once.
Mother-in-law should make sure to provide beer and dinner.
 
  • Like
ricebridge
  • Laddar…
Magnus E K
There is decking made from kärnfuru that is more attractive and environmentally friendly than pressure-treated wood. Or build a mold from scrap wood, throw in some stones and rebar, and cast a concrete staircase instead!
 
Magnus E K Magnus E K said:
There is decking made of heart pine that is nicer and more environmentally friendly than pressure-treated wood. Or build a mold out of scrap wood, throw in some stones and rebar, and cast a concrete staircase instead!
Considering that the rest of the house wasn't in such good condition and I perceived that the OP wanted the simplest possible solution, both heartwood (which has to be specially ordered?) and casting seem a bit overkill.
 
  • Like
ricebridge and 1 other
  • Laddar…
P patfred said:
Considering that the rest of the house wasn't in such great condition and I perceived that TS wanted the simplest possible effort, both core wood (which must be custom ordered?) and even casting feel a bit overkill
Exactly :-D
 
Magnus E K
I wouldn't have used pressure-treated in that case either, but instead untreated cheap timber which should last (since it's not directly on the ground) until the house is completely renovated/demolished/abandoned.
 
  • Like
tergo
  • Laddar…
I would have used a reciprocating saw to cut the bolts; with an angle grinder, there's a greater risk of accidentally setting the house on fire.
 
Magnus E K Magnus E K said:
I still wouldn't have used pressure-treated wood in that case, but rather untreated cheap wood, which should hold up (as it's not directly on the ground) until the house is completely renovated/demolished/abandoned.
Considering how small the steps are, maybe he saves 50-100 SEK by buying untreated wood? If even that
 
Magnus E K
P patfred said:
Considering how small the staircase is, he might save 50-100kr by buying non-treated wood? If even that
It's not (just) about the cost. I try to advocate for never using pressure-treated wood unless there are specific reasons for it.
 
Magnus E K Magnus E K said:
It's not just about the cost. I try to advocate for never using pressure-treated wood unless there are specific reasons for it.
Why?
 
Penetrating oil doesn't seem to have made much of a difference on the bolts, so I guess it's time for the angle grinder...
 
  • Like
ricebridge
  • Laddar…
Vi vill skicka notiser för ämnen du bevakar och händelser som berör dig.